• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Involvement & Participation Association Homepage

Raising Performance through Workplace Engagement
Contact us
  • About IPA
    • Who are IPA?
    • Our Team
      • The IPA Team
      • Our Work Insight Network
    • Jobs
    • History
    • Report and accounts
    • Contact Us
  • What we do
    • Overview of services
    • Strengthening Employment Relations
    • Learning & Development
      • Learning and development programmes
      • Training for Managers
      • Training for Representatives
    • Diagnostic reviews
    • Election Services
    • Speak at events
  • Evidence & Research
    • What is Employee Voice?
      • Making the case for employee voice
      • Employee Voice Hub
    • What is Employee Engagement?
      • Making the case for engagement
    • Collaborative Working
    • Why is diversity, equality and inclusion important?
    • Research Publications
    • Factsheets
    • Case Studies
    • Podcasts
  • IPA Membership
    • Corporate Membership
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events

IPA NEWS

Beyond Pay Talks: Why Information and Consultation Are the Missing Pillars in Modern Industrial Relations

October 27, 2026

Industrial relations in the UK is undergoing a structural shift. Much of the current focus -both organisationally and in policy debate – remains centred on collective pay bargaining. That focus is understandable: pay negotiations are visible, immediate, and often contentious. But they are only one part of the system.

The growing pressure on pay bargaining has exposed a deeper weakness: the absence of effective information and consultation (I&C) arrangements alongside negotiations. Without these, industrial relations becomes episodic, reactive, and more adversarial than necessary.

After decades of decline, the statutory framework has reaffirmed the importance of industrial relations within a modern economy. The challenge for practitioners is to now move beyond treating industrial relations as an annual pay event and instead use that framework to support a continuous, functioning sytem.

The Limits of a Pay-Centric Model

In many organisations, industrial relations still revolve around the pay cycle. Engagement intensifies as negotiations begin: positions are formed, conversations formalised, and solutions sought. Outside of that cycle, engagement often falls to minimum requirements (e.g. redundancy consultation). This creates three problems.

First, it compresses multiple issues into a single negotiation. Pay discussions become proxies for wider concerns – workload, change, fairness, organisational direction. They become overloaded not because the issues are inseparable, but because they have not been addressed earlier.

Second, it creates timing constraints. By the time negotiations begin, positions are already formed, leaving limited scope to shape thinking or build shared understanding. Discussions become more positional than exploratory.

Third, it leaves a vacuum between interactions. Issues that could have been addressed incrementally accumulate and surface later under pressure. Negotiations then become about everything that has gone unaddressed – not just pay.

This model is not inevitable, and it is not much fun. It reflects how industrial relations has been managed, rather than how it should function.

The Role of Information and Consultation

The Information and Consultation Regulations 2004 were designed to address this gap. Often overlooked, they provide a framework for structured dialogue outside formal negotiation. At their best, they deliver three outcomes.

Continuity. They enable ongoing dialogue about business performance, organisational priorities, and emerging workforce issues. This reduces the likelihood that pay negotiations become the first point at which concerns are surfaced.

Context. Effective industrial relations depends on a shared organisational narrative – a common frame of reference for discussion. Unlike the adversarial environment of formal negotiations, I&C forums create space to build mutual understanding. Without this, negotiations risk becoming detached from the realities shaping decisions.

Perspective. Employee voice is widely recognised as strengthening outcomes, yet it is often underutilised in adversarial bargaining environments. I&C forums provide a structured outlet for that voice, allowing issues to be explored before they escalate into disputes.

In short, I&C shifts industrial relations from a series of events to a continuous process.

The “Inform–Consult–Agree” Discipline

At the core of this approach is a simple principle – Inform, Consult, Agree.

Quietly embedded in UK statute, it clarifies the level of engagement required. Some issues require transparency; others require dialogue; a smaller number require negotiation and agreement.

In practice, many organisations struggle with either awareness or application. Issues that should be addressed in “inform” or “consult” settings are often neglected or deferred to the “agree” stage, where they become unnecessarily adversarial.

I&C structures fill this gap. They create space for discussion before negotiation is required and ensure that issues are not first raised at the bargaining table.

Where applied effectively, negotiations are more focused and productive. Where not, they become overloaded and contentious.

Why This Matters Now

Although I&C is not new, its relevance is growing.

Workforce expectations are changing. Employees are more informed, more engaged, and more willing to question decisions. Interest in trade unions is increasing, particularly among younger workers. At the same time, legislative developments are raising expectations of meaningful engagement.

In this environment, minimal engagement models are harder to sustain. Issues surface later, under greater pressure, with fewer options available. Organisations that invest in structured I&C alongside bargaining are better placed to shape conversations, manage expectations, and reduce unnecessary conflict.

Lessons from Practice

Babcock, a large defence engineering organisation operating across civilian and military domains, has historically managed industrial relations in an episodic, contract-based fashion.

Recognising the limits of this approach, it has begun to implement a more structured model built around the Inform – Consult – Agree framework.

Central to this is the creation of a national information and consultation forum to support the development of a shared narrative with our recognised trade unions. This model will be replicated across our business divisions. These forums sit alongside formal negotiations and meet regularly to establish a common narrative. The objective is not to eliminate conflict, but to build resilience by removing one of its most consistent drivers: surprise.

This work sits alongside the development of a group-wide dispute resolution procedure and a joint effort to build capability across managers, HR professionals, and union representatives in applying the Inform – Consult – Agree model effectively.

Moving Beyond Compliance

In many organisations, I&C is treated as a compliance exercise. This perspective understates its value.

Effective I&C is about capability. It enables structured engagement on complex issues and helps align understanding before formal negotiation is required. For this to work, these forums must support genuine dialogue. They must move beyond one-way communication and provide space for discussion and challenge. Without this, they add little value – and organisations default back to over-reliance on negotiation.

Conclusion: Completing the System

Pay bargaining will always be central to industrial relations. But it cannot carry the system alone.

Information and consultation provide the missing pillars: continuity, context, and early engagement. They allow industrial relations to function as a sustained capability rather than a series of pressured events.

Organisations that recognise this will approach negotiations from a position of stability and understanding. Those that do not will continue to experience them as reactive and overloaded.

Industrial relations becomes more effective not by intensifying negotiation, but by supporting it with the structures that make it work.

Byron Taylor, Group Head of Strategic Industrial Relations, Babcock International Group

About Byron Taylor

Byron is a Senior HR Leader with a specialist background in Industrial Relations, Employment Law & Employee Relations and delivering on diversity, equity and inclusion.

He has led global teams covering Europe, North America, Middle East, Africa, Asia, and Pacific regions and has a background in manufacturing, defence, science, finance, IT Consultancy, outsourcing, and the voluntary sectors.

More News Items
Better People Management in UK Warehouses
Better People Management in UK Warehouses
Information and consultation of employees – the dog that hasn’t barked (yet)
Information and consultation of employees – the dog that hasn’t barked (yet)

Sign up for our newsletter

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*

In partnership with

Involvement & Participation Association (IPA) is part of the Institute for Employment Studies (IES) a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales under number 931547 and registered as a charity number 258390

Home

About

Contact us

Registered office: Citygate, 185 Dyke Road, Brighton BN3 1TL | Privacy | Accessibility | Cookies

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}